ACW2 – HoTT Army Lists

I thought I’d pre-empt the Second American Civil War by putting together paired army lists for it. Apologies for the lapse in taste, but I’m so appalled by what’s going on in the US that I felt in need of a little catharsis…

Potus Provisionals

Behemoth Gen. x 1 – Trump [4 points]

Shooters x 4 – 1 x Homeland Security unit, 1 x Border Patrol unit,

1 x regular Police unit, 1 Secret Service unit [8 points]

Warband x 3 – Far Right militias, assorted weapons [6 points]

Lurkers x 2 – 1 x Fox News camera crew, 1 x reactionary Supreme Court Judge [2 points]

Hordes x 4 – Placard-waving supporters in MAGA hats [4 points]

Alternatives: Airboat x 1 – Trump Blimp [3 points]

Stronghold: Trump Tower or heavily fortified White House

Constitutionalists

Behemoth Gen. x 1 – Statue of Liberty [4 points]

Shooters x 2 – FBI Agents [4 points]

Blades x 4 – Regular Army units [8 points]

Lurkers x 1 – CNN camera crew [1 point]

Hordes x 7 – Placard-waving pro-democracy demonstrators [7 points]

Alternatives: Cleric x 1 – Joe Biden and Kamala Harris [3 points]; God x 1 – US Constitution [4 points]; Paladin x 1 – Bernie Saunders [4 points]

Stronghold: US Capitol Building or community centre

Grannies v Neo-Nazis

A Woman Hitting a Neo-Nazi With Her Handbag  is a photograph taken in Växjö, Sweden on 13 April 1985 by Hans Runesson. It depicts Danuta Danielsson hitting a marching neo-Nazi with a handbag. This HoTT list is loosely inspired by the photo, and is dedicated to the memory of Danuta, who died a few years after the photo was taken. And yes, I know she probably wasn’t actually a granny! For more information, click here.

Grannies

Hero General x 1 Danuta Danielsson swinging her handbag 4 points

Knights x 2 Grannies on mobility scooters 4 points

Blades x 2 Grannies with knitting needles 4 points

Warband x 4 Grannies wielding walking sticks, frying pans etc. 8 points

Shooter x 1 Grannies throwing boiled sweets 2 points

Beasts x 1 Granny walking small dogs in assorted dog jackets 2 points

Stronghold: Park benches set around a bandstand or ornamental flower bed

Alternatives: Flyers (Grannies on broomsticks); Magician (Granny giving pocket money to small child)

Neo-Nazis

Cleric x 1 Smartly dressed orator with thuggish ‘minders’ 3 points

Warband x 6 ‘Uniformed’ skinheads with baseball bats, razors etc. 12 points

Horde x 9 Less ‘committed’ fascists in ordinary street clothes 9 points

Stronghold: Bierkeller, or street section with open sewer cover (garnish liberally with rats)

Alternatives: Magician (Alt-Right keyboard warrior or yellow press journalist stirring up xenophobic sentiment from afar – thanks for the idea Dex McH!)

The Fall Of The Roman Empire

If you’re looking for a substantial bit of lockdown listening and/or reading, I can heartily recommend Peter Heather’s 2007 study of the collapse of the Roman Empire. I first downloaded it on Audible, but after listening to the whole book I realised that I also wanted a print copy for my collection – and in order to re-read some of the most important sections more carefully, particularly the final chapter in which Heather summarises his thesis about what lay behind Rome’s demise.

I should say at this point that I’m not a historian, so I can’t judge what the current consensus is, if any, on the main reasons for Rome’s collapse. Certainly when Heather first published this book his was – as he clearly states – a dissenting voice. Rather than accepting the thesis that the Empire collapsed as a result of internal weaknesses and divisions (a line that stems ultimately from Gibbon), Heather stresses the role of the barbarian invasions, with the Huns as a motor of those invasions both directly and indirectly. He makes a pretty strong case for this, and in a very accessible way.

The one aspect of the fall of the Western Empire which I think Heather does rather skirt over, is the impact of the Eastern Empire’s long-standing military contest with the Sassanians on their capacity to intervene in the West. This epic conflict, which ended with the Sassanians and the Romans fighting each other to a standstill, had a catastrophic long-term effect on both the combatants. Persia became easy prey for the armies of the Prophet, while Byzantium was both unable to continue its support for the Western Roman regime and ultimately unable to defend its own eastern possessions. While Heather’s thesis does take the Sassanian wars into account, I’m not sure that it gives them quite enough weight.

That’s a minor quibble however about what is overall a very solid account and a persuasive argument.

I have no idea whether Heather’s is still a left-field analysis, or whether it has since become the new orthodoxy. Either way his book is a very fine listen/read, with plenty of contemporary source material added into the mix. For anyone interested in this period of history, it’s well worth acquiring a copy.

Listening to Heather’s book inspired me to finally purchase the board game ‘Pandemic Fall of Rome’. Playing the original ‘Pandemic’ would just feel wrong in the present situation – too twisted even for someone with my sense of humour – but the ‘Fall of Rome’ variant is different enough to be acceptable. So far Keith and I have played a couple of games, both great fun. We won the first game easily – it’s a cooperative game, so you either win or lose together – but got a complete kicking in the second game! If you’d like to see a helpful overview of the game, check out Marco’s excellent video here – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q2rOEVkJPp0.

Till next time – happy gaming folks, and keep safe and well.

Solo DBA Rules

Solo DBA for DBA Version 2.2

With kind permission of Richard Lee, I am reproducing here the full version of the solo variant rules for DBA v2.2. These rules were originally produced and published in the Solo DBA Yahoo Group. They were developed from John Meunier’s “Random Terrain Placement” and Chad La Mons’ “De Bellis Solitarius”. They provide not just a full variant for DBA, but also a useful template for developing solo versions of other rulesets. Highly recommended!

1.Introduction

1.1.Description

Solo DBA provides a method of playing one side of a De Bellis Antiquitatis (DBA) game against a human opponent. The intention is that the automatic (non-human) player plays sensibly, but not too predictably. This terrain system, deployment and tactical engine were developed from “Random Terrain Placement” by John Meunier and “De Bellis Solitarius” by Chad La Mons, taken from the Fanaticus website.

This version is intended for DBA version 2.2.

1.2.Terminology

• NPG: The Non-Player’s General

• YOU/YOUR: Refers to you the human player (i.e. the NPG’s opponent)

• Bad Going Troops: Psiloi, Auxilia, Warband, Bow

2.Army Composition

Select which armies will be used by the NPG and YOU. Then:

2.1.Choose YOUR Army Options

If YOUR army has options, choose YOUR army’s composition before that of the NPG so that you do not sub-consciously take advantage of your knowledge of the NPG’s army composition.

2.2.NPG Army Composition

Work through the army list looking for options, but chose the general last (see below). Wherever there is an option, chose the elements by dicing. Select the option with the highest score (dicing again if more than one option had the highest score). Ignore any result that would cause an odd number of pike to be in the army.

2.2.1.NPG General

If the NPG has options for their general’s element, throw a dice for each option, apply relevant modifiers (see below), and then choose the option with the highest final score.

Modifiers

• -2 Will cause there to be an odd number of pike in the NPG army

• -2 Mounted (except elephant) general when YOU have 4 or more bows

• -2 General will be slower than any other element in the NPG’s army

• -1 Psiloi general

• -1 Elephant general when YOU have a total of 4 or more psiloi, auxilia, light horse, or any artillery

• +1 Infantry general of a troop type already present in NPG army

• +2 Mounted general of a troop type already present in NPG army

2.3.Attacker and Defender

Dice to determine which army is the attacker using the army aggression factors, as per the rules.

3.Terrain

If the NPG is the defender then select terrain from the NPG’s compulsory and optional features:

3.1.Compulsory Terrain

Select one instance of the compulsory terrain feature. Arable terrain has 2 options for compulsory terrain.

3.1.1.Arable Compulsory Terrain

For ‘Arable’ terrain the compulsory terrain may be either a Built-UP Area (BUA) or road(s). Some players don’t use BUAs. Players who do use BUAs should throw a D6, apply the modifiers and refer to the table:

Arable Terrain Compulsory Feature
Dice Roll	Terrain Feature
Up to 3	BUA
4 or more	Road

Modifiers

• +1 Defender has 5 or more mounted elements

• +2 Defender has a total of less than 6 spear and blade

• +2 Attacker has artillery

• +3 Defender has no spear or blade but the attacker does

3.1.2.Multiple Compulsory Terrain Features

Some compulsory terrain types may have 2 pieces. For Woods, Steep Hills, Gentle Hills, Rough or Road throw a D6. If the defender has a total of more than 6 bad-going elements, add 1 for Woods, Steep Hills or Rough. If the score is 4 or more then select a second compulsory terrain feature.

3.2.Optional Terrain

3.2.1.Number of Features

Determine whether there will be 2 or 3 optional terrain features. Throw a D6, apply the modifiers and consult the table:

Number of Optional Features
Dice Roll	Number
Up to 3	2
4 or more	3

Modifiers

• +2 Defender has more bad going elements than attacker

• +1 Attacker has more mounted than defender

• -1 Compulsory terrain includes 2 pieces of bad going

• -1 Defender has more mounted than attacker

• -1 Attacker has more bad going troops than defender

3.2.2.Littoral Options

Littoral terrain may have either steep hills or marsh. It may have either woods or dunes. If the defending army has littoral terrain, decide whether steep hills or marsh are appropriate. If both are appropriate for the defending army, throw 2 dice, 1 for steep hills and the other for marsh. Ignore the terrain type with the lower score when dicing to select terrain. Use a similar procedure to choose between woods and dunes.

3.2.3.Optional Terrain Selection

For each optional terrain feature for the defending army, throw a D6. Some terrain features may have up to 2 instances; for these throw a D6 for each possible occurrence. If attacker has littoral terrain and a waterway is an optional item of terrain for the defender then subtract 1 from the waterway’s score.

There must be at least one feature that is bad going, a Waterway or a River. If this has not already been chosen as compulsory terrain then select the relevant feature with the highest score. Select the other optional terrain features from those with the highest scores. If necessary, re-roll for ties.

3.3.Terrain Placement

“Near baseline”, “far baseline”, “right” and “left” refer to the current position of the human player during terrain placement. It is assumed that the human will be seated in the same position during terrain placement.

Re-roll for any result that would be illegal under the rules or is impossible because of terrain already placed.

3.3.1.Place Waterway

If a waterway has been selected as one of the terrain features then place it first. A waterway must be on one edge of the playing area. Throw a dice then refer to the table below:

Waterway Placement
Dice Result	Position of Waterway
1-2	Right side of Battlefield
3-4	Left side of Battlefield
5	Far baseline
6	Near baseline

3.3.2.Place Built–Up Area

If a built-up area (BUA) has been chosen place it next. A BUA must fit completely within a 900 pace square rectangle in a corner. Throw a dice then refer to the table below for the approximate position:

Built Up Area Placement
Dice Result	BUA Position
1-2	Near baseline on right
3-4	Near baseline on left
5	Far baseline on right
6	Far baseline on left

3.3.3.Place River

Rivers go from one edge to the opposite. They can meander (bend) so that they are up to 1¹/₂ times the distance between the ends. They must avoid going within 600 paces of any battlefield edge except where they start and finish. They are allowed to cross 2 battlefield quarters only.

Throw a dice then refer to the table below:

River Placement
Dice Result	Position of River
1-2	Left to right, between 12” and 18” from near baseline
3	Left to right, between 6” and 12” from near baseline
4	Near baseline to far baseline, between 6” and 12” from left side
5-6	Near baseline to far baseline, between 12” and 18” from left side

3.3.4.Place Other Area Terrain

Notionally divide the board into 9 sectors of equal size. For each piece of area terrain, roll two 2D6 of different colour to determine sector. All area features must have at least 50% of their area in the sector designated by the dice. If only one piece of Bad Going terrain is selected, it must straddle two quarters of the board in order to meet the rules for terrain placement in DBA.

Area Terrain Placement
First Die	Second Die
1,2 = left	1,2 = near baseline
3,4 = centre	3,4 = middle
5,6 = right	5,6 = far baseline

3.3.5.Place Roads

If one or more roads have been selected and there is a built-up area (BUA) one road must contact or pass through it.

Roads go from one battlefield edge to the opposite. They can bend slightly to avoid other terrain features but should otherwise be fairly straight. They must not cross more than 2 battlefield quarters, so take care when placing them near the middle of the battlefield. Where they cross rivers is either a ford or bridge, depending upon whether or not a model bridge is available.

Notionally divide the battlefield in 9 sectors. For each road throw 1dice. Refer to the table below:

Dice Result	Road Position
1	Left to Right close to near baseline
2	Left to right close to middle
3	Left to right close to far baseline
4	Near baseline to far baseline, left side of battlefield
5	Near baseline to far baseline, middle of battlefield
6	Near baseline to far baseline, right side of battlefield

4.Deployment

4.1.Base Edge Selection for NPG Attacker

For a NPG attacker, select the preferred edge to deploy. For any edge not adjacent to a BUA (built-up area), throw a dice. Choose the edge that has the highest total score after applying the following modifiers:

Modifiers

• +3 Deployment zone is clear of rivers and bad going

• +3 The opposite deployment zone has a reasonable sized area of bad going near its centre

• +1 The opposite deployment zone has bad going within 6” in front of it and YOUR army has 6 or more elements of Knights, Cavalry, Light Horse, or Camelry

• +1 Deployment zone has gentle hills

• -1 The opposite deployment zone has bad going within 6” in front of it and YOUR army has 8 or more elements of Bad Going Troops

• -1 Waterway on the flank of the deployment zone and YOU have littoral terrain type

• -2 Waterway on the rear of the deployment zone and YOU have littoral terrain type

• -2 Deployment zone has bad going within 6” in front of it and NPG army does not have 8 or more elements of Auxilia or Psiloi

• -3 Deployment zone has a reasonable sized area of bad going near its centre

Once the preferred edge is selected, dice as per the DBA rules to determine which edge the NPG deploys on.

4.2.Camp Garrison

If the NPG has a camp, garrison it by either camp followers or spear. If the NPG army has spear, then throw a dice and add any modifiers that apply. If the result is 6 or more, garrison the camp with spear.

Modifiers

• +2 YOU have light horse

• +1 NPG has an odd number of spear

• +1 YOU have more mounted than NPG

4.3.Camp Placement

The NPG camp is placed according to the following rules in descending order of preference:

• Avoid a flank with a waterway if YOU have littoral terrain

• Avoid roads coming from the YOUR side

• Position camp behind bad going if available

• Position camp as close to the centre as terrain and the other rules permit

4.4.Built Up Area Garrison

Armies with infantry may garrison a built up area (BUA). Roll a D6, apply modifiers, then consult the table:

Built-Up Area
Die Roll	Garrison?
Up to 3	No
4 or more	Yes

Modifiers

• +2 Defender has Blade

• +1 Attacker has no infantry except Psiloi

• +1 Defender has Spear

• -1 Attacker has Spear or elephant

• -1 Attacker has Psiloi as well as Auxilia, Spear or Blade, or more than one Spear

• -2 Attacker has Blade or more than 1 pike

• -2 Defender has no infantry except for bows or psiloi

• -3 BUA in Defender’s side

Use the following rules in descending order of preference to select a garrison:

1. Pick blade if their number is not divisible by 3

2. Pick spear if there is an odd number of spear

3. Pick blade

4. Pick spear

5. Pick pike if there are an odd number of pike

6. Pick artillery

7. Pick horde

8. Pick auxilia

9. Pick warband

4.5.Tactical Groups

Form tactical groups of up to 4 elements each. If there is more than one mounted element then there must be at least two tactical groups containing mounted. The tactical groups should be of the same element type except for the following exceptions:

• Psiloi elements are committed to support blades, spears or auxilia if YOUR army contains a combined total of more than 3 mounted and warband elements. Priority of allocating psiloi is given to wherever they can provide rear support for 3 elements of the same type;

• Bows are interspersed with spear or blade elements if YOUR army has more than 3 mounted;

• Spears, blades or pikes may be combined within the same group. Pikes should be grouped in even numbers, if possible;

• Elephants may be grouped with up to a total of two other elements: auxilia, psiloi if YOUR army has no more than 2 mounted, or knights if YOUR army has 3 or more mounted.

• Excluding elephants, mounted elements may be grouped with other types of mounted elements.

4.6.Littoral Landing

Armies with littoral terrain may do a littoral landing if there is a waterway. If the NPG army has littoral terrain throw a dice and apply the modifiers below. If the total is 6 or more then the NPG may reserve troops for a littoral landing.

Modifiers

• +3 NPG is attacker

• +2 YOUR camp is within 6 inches from the waterway

• +1 There is bad going terrain near the centreline, near the waterway and NPG has auxilia (or camels if the bad going is dunes)

• +1 YOU have 10 or more elements that move 300 paces or less in good going

• +1 NPG has 8 or more elements that can move at least 300 paces in good going

• +1 YOUR army does not have littoral terrain

• +1 YOUR army has stronger infantry (more pike, blade and spear) than NPG

• -1 NPG has any elephants, artillery, horde or warwagons

• -1 NPG general moves at 200 paces in good going

• -2 Waterway at YOUR rear and NPG is defender

• -2 YOU as defender have deployed troops within 3 inches from YOUR camp

• -12 NPG is attacker and YOU have reserved 2 or more elements for a littoral landing

4.7.Deployment Position

There are 4 major positions within the deployment zone: ‘Centre’, is in the centre two quarters of the deployment zone, up to the furthest forward deployment position; ‘Reserve’, is 200 paces behind the centre position; ‘Right Flank’, is to the right of the deployment zone, up to 600 paces from the NPG baseline; ‘Left Flank’, is on the left of the deployment zone, up to 600 paces from the NPG baseline.

Throw 2 dice and add their score, apply the modifiers then refer to the table to decide where to attempt to deploy each group:

Deployment of Groups
Dice Score	Position
4 or less	Reserve
5-9	Centre
10	Left Flank
11	Right Flank
12 or more	Littoral Landing/Right Flank

Modifiers

• -5 Mounted General which is the only mounted element

• -5 Infantry facing good-going when YOU have more infantry with high combat factors against infantry in good going and NPG has more mounted

• -3 Cavalry, Camelry, knights, blades or spears and YOU have reserved troops for a littoral landing

• -3 Mounted if both flanks are bad going

• +2 Psiloi or auxilia

• +3 Tactical group contains elephants or knights and is not the general who is the only mounted

• +3 Bad going troops and both flanks are bad going

• +4 Cavalry, Camelry, Light Horse and is not the general who is the only mounted element

Flanks may be joined to the Centre, or may have a gap between them and the Centre if they need to avoid a terrain feature. The Centre should be centred in the middle of the game board unless there are major tactical reasons not to, e.g. inconvenient terrain ahead. The Reserve is paced 200p behind the frontline.

It is possible to have the whole NPG army in one massive group in one area (e.g. Centre, Reserve, etc.). For example, the die results have three groups of Spartan spear being placed in the Centre. The Spartans are thus placed in a huge phalanx, which might be 2 ranks deep, 6 elements abreast or a line of 12 elements.

Deploy the groups following these rules:

1. Deploy pikes in 2 ranks;

2. A maximum of 4 elements may be used for a littoral landing. If more than 4 elements are chosen for a littoral landing then throw a dice for each tactical group and select the one with the highest score. Elements not used for a littoral landing are deployed on the right flank.

3. Do not deploy psiloi facing cavalry, camelry or knight with no bad going between them;

4. Do not deploy war wagons or elephants facing within one base width of YOUR artillery;

5. Deploy troops in column if they are in, or will soon enter bad going, or to avoid deploying in bad going. Otherwise deploy in line if space permits.

6. If the NPG army has 6 or more warband elements, throw a D6; on a 1-3 deploy the elements in two ranks; otherwise deploy one warband element on each flank of the group (one rank deep) with the remaining in two ranks;

7. If YOUR army has 5 or more spear elements and the NPG army has 6 or more spear elements, throw a D6: on a 1-3 deploy the elements in two ranks; otherwise deploy one spear element on each flank of the group (one rank deep) with the remaining in two ranks;

8. The fastest elements are placed on the outer extremities of a position unless that will mean mounted troops facing or being deployed in bad going. Fastest mounted have priority over slower mounted;

9. Deploy the general as close to the centre of the position as is consistent with the other rules;

10. If non-bad going troops are to be positioned on a flank in bad going or that has bad going ahead within 600 paces then deploy them on the other flank if that is clear of bad going;

Some placements may be impractical due to the presence of impassable terrain or terrain an element cannot enter (e.g. the die roll indicates that a group of two Ottoman bombards are to be placed on the left flank where there is a large bad going marsh). Since Artillery can’t be placed off-road in bad-going, the 2 Artillery must roll for a new position.).

4.8.NPG Defender Option to Swap Elements

Once YOU have deployed, use your tactical judgement whether or not to swap up to the 2 pairs of elements that the defender is allowed to do for the NPG. Look to see which elements on YOUR side are facing those of the NPG. Ignore any matches where there is bad going or impassable terrain between them. Try to avoid bad match-ups for the NPG and try to create bad-match ups for YOU.

4.8.1.Bad Match-Ups

• Psiloi faced by cavalry, camelry or knights

• Elephants faced by psiloi, auxilia, light horse or artillery

• Knight faced by elephants, scythed chariots, light horse or bows

• Cavalry, camelry ,light horse or warband faced by scythed chariots

• Pikes or spears faced by elephants, knights or scythed chariots

• Blades faced by knights or scythed chariots

• Hordes faced by elephants, knights, scythed chariots, warband, bows or artillery

• War wagons faced by elephants or artillery

5.Tactical Engine

5.1.Actions

The tactical engine guides the NPG by prioritising the actions that the NPG may make. The actions are:

• Aggressive Attack – Attack YOUR troops by shooting or close combat whenever there is an equal of the NPG killing YOUR elements compared to YOUR chance of killing NPG elements;

• Aggressive Manoeuvre – Move NPG troops to either threaten YOUR troops or facilitate a future attack;

• Calculated Attack – Attack YOUR troops by shooting or close combat whenever there is a better chance of destroying YOUR elements than NPG elements;

• Defensive Manoeuvre – Move NPG troops to defend against a threat from YOUR troops, e.g. to face a flank attack or to move psiloi into bad going to protect against YOUR cavalry;

• Form Column – A group forms a column, usually to facilitate passing through bad going or a gap;

• Form Line – Columns form line,

• Occupy Terrain – Move bad going troops forward to occupy bad going or a hill;

• Re-arrange Line – Move NPG troops so that they change position within an existing group, e.g. widen a group by putting elements in rear support into the front line, putting elements from the front rank into rear support or moving rear support;

• Reckless Attack – Attack YOUR troops by shooting or close combat when there is a chance of the NPG killing YOUR troops but YOU have a higher chance of killing the NPGs;

• Re-enforce – Move NPG troops towards an existing group or single element as a re-enforcement;

• Repair Line – Move elements that have been recoiled or pushed back, or which have been brought to within one move away from their anticipated position, into position in a line.

• Safe Attack – Attack YOUR troops by shooting or close combat whenever there is a chance of destroying YOUR elements but no chance of destroying NPG elements;

• Support Attack – Attack or shoot as part of a coordinated attack on YOUR forces, i.e. attack to make a simultaneous attack on YOUR forces more effective;

5.2.Aggression Level

The aggression level determines whether or not the NPG tends to play aggressively or defensively throughout the game. It is determined once, at the start of the first NPG bound, and affects what the NPG does in all following bounds.

Throw a dice. Apply the modifiers then refer to the table below.

Modifiers

• +2 NPG has 5 or more mounted elements

• +1 NPG has an army with eleven or more elements that move at least 300 paces in good going

• +1 NPG has 6 or more warband and YOUR army has 6 or more spear

• -1 NPG has a total of more than 4 auxilia and psiloi and YOU have a total of more than 4 cavalry, knights, blades and spear;

• -2 NPG has a total of 6 or more spear, blades and pike

Dice Plus Modifiers	Aggression Level
2 or less	Defensive
3 or 4	Neutral
5 or more	Aggressive

5.3.Each NPG Bound

At the start of each NPG bound roll 2 dice. (It is helpful to use different coloured dice.) The first die determines PIPs. The second die determines the NPG tactical stance for this bound (essentially what element(s) shall warrant priority in expending move points).

NPG Tactical Stance
Die Roll	Battle Plan
0-2	Defensive
3-4	Cautious
5+	Aggressive

Modifiers

• -1 Each element the NPG has lost

• -1 NPG has ‘defensive’ aggression level

• -1 NPG has 1 or 2 PIPs

• +1 Each element YOU have lost

• +1 NPG has ‘aggressive’ aggression level

• +1 NPG has 5 or 6 PIPs

• +4 NPG has lost 3 elements but YOU have lost 2 or less

Permitted moves for the 3 tactical stances are listed in descending order of priority. Exercise your best tactical judgment, but attempt to find useful higher priority moves for the appropriate tactical stance in preference to the lower priority moves. Consider using the ‘Tactical Engine Override’ (see below) if the tactical engine seems to be making a very bad choice.

Permitted Moves for the NPG Tactical Stances in Descending Order of Priority
Aggressive	Cautious	Defensive
Safe Attack Support Attack Calculated Attack Aggressive Attack Aggressive Manoeuvre Reckless Attack Occupy Terrain Defensive Manoeuvre Re-enforce Repair Line Form Line	Defensive Manoeuvre Safe Attack Support Attack Occupy Terrain Calculated Attack Aggressive Manoeuvre Form Line Re-enforce Form Column Repair Line	Repair Line Defensive Manoeuvre Re-enforce Form Line Occupy Terrain Safe Attack Support Attack Calculated Attack Aggressive Manoeuvre

5.4.Tactical Engine Override

Sometimes the tactical engine will either miss opportunities or not allow the NPG to deal with significant risks. There are a maximum of three opportunities per game to dice whether or not to ignore the choices that the tactical engine makes for that bound. An opportunity is used whether or not the dice allows the tactical engine to be overridden.

Throw a dice. If the score is 3 or more then ignore the tactical engine for this bound. If the score is 1 or 2 then follow the dictates of the tactical engine for this bound.

Machiavellian Renaissance HoTT

by Jay Blackwood…

Contrary to the bad press he’s received, Nicolo Machiavelli was a nice boy – I mean, just look at that sweet smile! On the other hand, when it came to pondering military matters, he was a bit of a duffer. He believed pikemen would be outmatched by troops wielding sword and buckler; that firearms and artillery would have a limited impact on the contemporary battlefield; and that cavalry would mainly function as skirmishers. His errors stemmed, according to the historian Sir Charles Oman, from a misreading of recent battles and – crucially – from a misguided attempt to apply the ‘lessons’ of classical warfare to the Renaissance era. In particular, Nicolo believed that the triumph of the Roman maniple over the Successor pike block would be replicated in his own day.

Machiavelli’s musings do however provide the basis for a rather different sort of Renaissance Italian army, as detailed below…

Basic Army

1 Knight General (the Prince) @ 2 AP = 2 AP

6 Blades (infantry armed with sword and buckler, Spanish style) @ 2 AP = 12 AP

2 Spears (Italian pikemen) @ 2 AP = 4 AP

2 Shooters (arquebusiers) @ 2 AP = 4 AP

1 Rider (light horse armed with crossbows or guns) @ 2 AP = 2 AP

Optional Extras

1 Sneaker (Machiavelli, with a cunning plan) @ 3 AP

1 Horde (admiring Princes) @ 1 AP

1 Artillery (catapult firing copies of classical military texts) @ 3 AP

1 Behemoth (Da Vinci tank) @ 4 AP

1 Magician (a Renaissance alchemist or necromancer) @ 4 AP

1 Flyer (Da Vinci flying contraption) @ 2 AP

Stronghold

An Italianate tower or fortified house – must have own library!

Of Mice And Frogs

Guest post on Brachatomyomachia for HoTT by Bernie F.

Homer was the most popular and admired poet of the ancient world. Of course he was also read in schools and probably bored thousands of pupils to death. So it’s not a surprise that parodies on his poems were written. One of them, a parody of the Iliad, had the title “Brachatomyomachia” (“The Battle of Frogs and Mice”) and in antiquity was even thought to be composed by Homer himself. Actually, however, it had probably been written in the 1st century BC by an author living in or near Alexandria in (or rather “at”, as the Ancients would have said) Egypt. The little poem of about 300 lines was very popular both in antiquity and the middle ages and has come down to us in dozens of manuscripts. And it still makes a good read.

A Summary

Psicharpax (“Thief of crumbs”), son of the mouse king Troxartes (“Bread nibbler”), drinking water from a lake meets the frog king Physignathos (“Chubby Cheek(s)”), who invites him to his “palace”. As the frog king swims across the lake, the mouse prince seated on his back, they are confronted by a frightening watersnake. The frog dives, forgetting about his passenger, who drowns. Another mouse witnesses the scene from the bank of the lake, and runs to tell everyone about it. The mice arm themselves for battle to avenge the frog king’s treachery, and send a herald to the frogs with a declaration of war. The frogs first blame their king, who by telling them a barefaced lie about the real circumstances persuades them to go to war. In the meantime, Zeus, seeing the brewing war, proposes that the gods take sides. Athena refuses, saying that both mice and frogs have done her a lot of mischief, adding “No, gods, let us refrain from helping these hosts, or one of us may get wounded with a sharp spear; for they fight hand to hand, even if a god comes against them.“ And so it happens. A bloody battle ensues and eventually the Mice prevail, not the least because of their great hero Meridarpax (“Stealer of small bits” or “Slice snatcher”, as an English translation says). As the gods themselves are afraid to fight this mighty hero and even Zeus’ thunderbolt does not stop the mice, he summons a force of crayfish or crabs to prevent complete destruction of the Frogs. Powerless against the armoured crabs, the Mice retreat, and the one-day war ends at sundown.

Heroes, Equipment And Troop Types

In the poem the mice seem to have more and greater heroes than the frogs. I prefer to classify the latter’s champions as »sneakers«, since a certain Prassaios (“Greencoat”) “presses through those in front of him” to support his king against the mouse king. In the same scene his companion Origanios (a name connected to “oreganum”; the English translation gives “Rueful”, while a German one I own prefers the more proper “Bitterling”) is called “the only one distinguishing himself in the frog army”, so he alone (or the king if accompanied by him) would deserve to classified as »hero«. Anyway, the mice should have at least one hero more than the frogs.

About the equipment of the mice we read: “First they fastened greaves to their shins made from yellow bean-pods broken into two parts which they had gnawed out, standing over them all night. Their breast plates were of skin stretched on reeds, skilfully made from a ferret they had flayed. For shields (aspides) each had the centrepiece of a lamp, and their spears (the Greek word used is longchai,  plural of longche) were
long needles, the all-bronze instruments of Ares, and the helmets upon their temples were chickpea shells.”

This equipment may be only that of a precious few, as the mice had only one ferret flayed and certainly won’t have a large numbers of lamps available. The rank and file may have been unarmoured and had simple shields, if any. Instead of the spear the mighty Meridarpax “splitting a chestnut-husk into two parts along the joint, put the two hollow pieces as weapons on his paws”.

The frogs’ equipment is similar to that of the mice, but made of more readily available material: “They wrapped around their shins leaves of mallows, and had breastplates made of fine green beet-leaves, and cabbage-leaves, skilfully fashioned, for shields (again aspides). Each one was equipped with a long, pointed rush for a spear (again, the word longchai is used, and smooth snail-shells to cover their heads.” (the first example of completely biodegradable armour, it seems). The differences between the several types of leg protection is interesting, by the way: the mice use classic greaves, while the frogs wrap a flexible (and presumably thick) material around their shins.

In spite of the breast plates and the round shields I prefer to classify the infantry of both sides as a kind of peltasts or, in the terms of HOTT, as »warband« (perhaps with an option for grading the mice as »spears«). This also suits the nature of the combatants.

The Frogs

Warband General @ 2AP – Physignathos, king of the frogs

Sneakers x 2 @ 3AP – Assorted frog champions like Seutlaios and Borborokoites

Warband x 7 @ 2AP – Ordinary frog warriors

Water Lurkers x 2  @ 1AP – Ambushers

Total Cost: 24AP
Stronghold: Pond.

Variants: Hero General (Physignathos if accompanied by several frog champions like Prassaios and Origanios) or Hero (Origanios) @ 4AP, God (Zeus or other Olympians, if
they ever dare to appear) @ 4AP, Behemoths @ 4AP or Beasts @ 2AP (the crayfish army send by Zeus), Hordes (less well motivated warriors) @ 1AP.

The Mice

Hero General x 1 @ 4AP – Troxartes, king of the mice, accompanied by several lesser heroes

Hero x 1 @ 4AP – “The Mighty Meridarpax”

Sneakers  x 1 @ 3AP – Lesser mouse champions

Warband x 6 @ 2AP – Ordinary mouse warriors

Land Lurker x 1 @ 1AP – Ambushers

Total Cost: 24AP
Stronghold: Mouse-hole.

Variants: Flyers (Mosquitos) @ 2AP, Spears (alternative classification of the warriors, may therefore not be used with warbands) @ 2AP, Hordes (less well motivated mice like Meridarpax’ father) @ 1AP